I think the issue with the
Recaro convertible seats...is the info coming out prior to the seats said that they would have lock-offs. And that's even what the first instruction books had and what was on their website(I believe). A lock-off takes the place of a locking clip, locking the belt when the belt does not lock on it's own in a non-emergency situation. Maybe
Recaro didn't understand the defination before they made their seats and wrote their instruction manuals. For parents---a locking clip can appear confusing and hard to use...and many are just plain scared of them. So a lock-off offers a way around that and doesn't seem nearly as daunting.
Also from what I understand
Recaro has lock-offs at the
rear facing belt path. I don't understand why
Recaro has choosen to have lock-offs or "belt clamps" for
RF, but not
FF.
It does seem to me, at least, that
Recaro said that they would have lock-offs, and then when they didn't perform as they were supposed-
Recaro decided to change the name and function rather than do a recall and provide a replacement peice that would work as originally intended. Furthermore---I just check the online version of the
Signo instruction manual. I did not see anywhere in there that you would need a locking clip. And the instructions for installing via the non-locking Lap/shoulder ELR belt seemed to indicate that the belt guide would hold the belt tight, when we know that is NOT the case. There is NO directions that include needing a locking clip with a non-locking belt.
Recaro should INCLUDE the locking clip if it's needed. It shouldn't be something a parent needs to go buy at the store or have to wait for you to mail to them. Meanwhile they are driving around with their child unsafe or stuck at home while they are waiting. Or even worse---not realize that their child is unsafe and drive around without a locked seatbelt. Let me also go on to say--that in my CPST course we learned that you don't use both a lock-off and a locking clip. If you do, you're risking the child to be a real life crash test dummy.
I also think that companies need to use the same terminology when referring to seats parts such as splitter plate, harness straps, retainer clip. Having to learn different vocabulary for each seat/brand will only contribute to more misuse.
Until I've tested a
Recaro convertible for myself to see how they work--and if they work according to their own manual(and your above post contridicts the manual), then I'm not comfortable reccomending them to parents.
Susan