I agree with PP. I would actually look into getting your youngest a new seat vs your oldest a new one. There are so many great seats out on the market that are lesser in price and have great features. Evenflo Triumph ADVANCE will
RF to 35lbs and
FF to 50lbs.
When your oldest gets closer to outgrowing the
Marathon, the seat will likely be getting close to expiration (6 years from date of manufacture) and you can re-evaluate your situation then.