View Single Post

  #2 (permalink)  
Old 09-11-2007, 11:10 AM
Papooses's Avatar
Papooses Papooses is offline
Moderator & CPS Tech (t631605)
 
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: NY
Posts: 410
Thanks: 4
Thanked 8 Times in 8 Posts
Rep Power: 189
Papooses has much to be proud ofPapooses has much to be proud ofPapooses has much to be proud ofPapooses has much to be proud ofPapooses has much to be proud ofPapooses has much to be proud ofPapooses has much to be proud ofPapooses has much to be proud ofPapooses has much to be proud ofPapooses has much to be proud of
Default

The Radian would be the safest seat more long-term because it has the high weight limit + higher top harness slots, but it can be difficult to install correctly: what is the vehicle year/make/model Would your next carseat be installed in the center or outboard?

The Safeguard Go meets the same safety standards as every other carseat & the higher harness weight limit (compared to the Chase or CarGo) is more ideal. However the Go is more suited to travel purposes because once the harness is outgrown it becomes merely a backless booster. Since we do not yet have side impact crash test requirements in the U.S. I don't know how the Go might perform in such real life crashes. I do know that highback boosters are about 70% safer in side impact crashes even without deep head wings, but more dedicated boosters (such as the Britax Monarch, Compass B510, Graco Airbooster, Recaro Vivo, etc.) that do have deep head wings filled with energy absorbing EPS/EPP foam offer even more protection.

Harnesses are safest in side impacts, though & it stands to reason that one with a sturdier back would probably be safer than one without, but we don't have comprehensive enough comparative data to know exactly how much safer

Have you considered the Cosco Apex? So long as the vehicle offers head support at least up to eye level (as the child grows) then this would be a good choice It has the same limits as the Go, but with a firm back + some head wings (it's also lightweight enough for travel)
__________________
Tiffany's Child Passenger Safety Website

READ/FOLLOW BOTH CARSEAT + VEHICLE MANUALS!
The best carseat fits the child, fits the vehicle & is always used correctly....
Get your seat checked.

Last edited by Papooses; 09-11-2007 at 11:13 AM.
Reply With Quote